SongTrace

Same song, different credits: why the musicians don’t match

You search a song, then a friend finds a different list of musicians for it. Both can be right. Here is why.

By SongTrace · Published 10 November 2026 · 4 min read

A song is not a recording

The first thing to separate is the song from the recording. A song, as a piece of writing, can be performed and recorded by many people. Each recording has its own musicians. “Gentle on My Mind” was written by John Hartford, and the version most people know was recorded by Glen Campbell, but other artists have recorded it too, and each of those recordings has a different lineup.

The same goes for “Hallelujah”. Leonard Cohen wrote it, and Jeff Buckley’s 1994 recording on Grace is a different recording with different musicians. When you search by title alone you may find all of them, which is why adding the artist matters.

An LP record in a paper inner sleeve, with its label visible.
Each release carries its own credits. Two pressings of the same song can print different information.Photo: J.P.Lon · CC BY-SA 3.0 · Source: Wikimedia Commons

Why two pages can disagree

  • Different recordings. A studio version, a live version and a demo are separate recordings with separate players, even when the title and the artist are the same.
  • Different releases. A single, an album, a compilation and a remaster may each print their own credits. Reissues sometimes drop information from the original.
  • Different kinds of source. MusicBrainz attaches credits to a specific recording, so you can see who played on one version and not on another. Discogs attaches credits to a release, so they can include people who played on other tracks of the same release.
  • Different level of detail. Some sources list the album as a whole, others track by track, so one page may have a complete lineup where another has two names.

Remasters and reissues

A remastered edition usually does not change who played, but it can change what is printed. It may add new credits, such as the mastering engineer, and it may leave out others. If a lineup looks different on a reissue, compare it with the original release before deciding which is right.

Sources

The facts in this story were checked against the pages below (the Wikipedia pages are in English). Credits can differ between sources, so for anything important compare with the original release.

Share this story